SHORT ANSWER
At $59 a month, the crossover is $590.
Substack’s 10% platform fee equals beehiiv Lite’s $59 monthly entry price at $590 in monthly paid newsletter revenue. Above that revenue, the percentage fee is higher. This compares platform fees only—not net income or the total cost of running a newsletter.
CALCULATOR
Put your revenue against the fixed fee.
Entry-tier prices only, at 1,000 subscribers. Paid beehiiv prices rise with subscriber tier; the plan’s maximum audience is not included at its entry price. Inputs stay in your browser and are not sent or stored.
THE MATH
A fixed fee divided by a revenue share.
Substack platform fee = monthly paid revenue × 0.10
Break-even monthly revenue = beehiiv monthly platform cost ÷ 0.10
The signed monthly difference is Substack’s fee minus beehiiv’s selected cost. A positive result means Substack costs more in this model; a negative result means it costs less. Annualized difference multiplies the monthly difference by 12, assuming unchanged revenue, subscriber tier and prices. Displayed amounts round to cents.
PRICE REALITY
Four entry-price comparisons.
| beehiiv plan / billing | Monthly cost | Break-even revenue / month |
|---|---|---|
| Lite / monthly | $59 | $590 |
| Lite / annual | $49 equivalent | $490 |
| Pro / monthly | $109 | $1,090 |
| Pro / annual | $95 equivalent | $950 |
Annual billing means an annual commitment: $588 for Lite or $1,140 for Pro at these entry prices, not a monthly payment of $49 or $95. Lite supports up to 100,000 subscribers and Pro up to 250,000, at prices that vary by subscriber tier.
beehiiv Free is $0 for up to 2,500 subscribers; Enterprise has custom pricing. This paid-plan comparison uses Lite and Pro. Substack publishing is free regardless of subscriber count; paid subscriptions incur its 10% platform fee.
PAYMENT PROCESSING
Zero platform share does not mean zero fees.
beehiiv takes 0% of paid-subscription revenue as a platform fee, but payment-processing costs may still apply. Substack lists its 10% fee separately from Stripe processing: its US-card example is 2.9% + $0.30 per payment, plus 0.7% Stripe Billing for recurring payments. Substack’s optional custom domain costs $50 once.
These charges are excluded from the calculator. Payment method, country and billing behavior can change processing costs; do not treat the headline result as a complete net-income comparison.
SOFTPINION TAKE
A crossover is a decision input, not a winner.
When beehiiv may cost less
Paid revenue exceeds the relevant crossover, useful growth or monetization tools add value, and you operate the newsletter as a business. Check your actual subscriber-tier quote before switching.
When Substack may still make sense
You prefer no fixed platform subscription, paid revenue is below the crossover, or simplicity, network and distribution benefits outweigh the platform-fee difference.
ASSUMPTIONS / LIMITATIONS
Price the list you actually have.
The model holds subscriber tier, revenue and prices constant. It excludes processing, taxes, refunds, discounts, migration effort, optional domain fees and the value of features or distribution. It does not predict earnings, subscriber growth or savings. Enter paid-subscription revenue only, not advertising or other business revenue. Values from $0 to $1 billion with up to two decimal places are supported.
For context, read beehiiv vs Substack, beehiiv pricing and Is beehiiv worth it?.
Check your subscriber-tier price.
Softpinion may earn a commission if you sign up for beehiiv through links on this page, at no additional cost to you.
Only beehiiv is monetized. Substack does not compensate Softpinion for this page.
See beehiiv plansSOURCES
Published terms behind the model.
- beehiiv Help Center: plan types and subscriber tiers
- beehiiv current plans
- beehiiv October 1 pricing-change announcement
- beehiiv pricing guide, updated October 13, 2026
- Substack official pricing and fees
Facts checked October 26, 2026. Calculations and decision framing are Softpinion analysis; no hands-on product testing is claimed.