PRICE REALITY
Audience size and paid revenue are different cost drivers.
beehiiv Free is $0 for up to 2,500 subscribers. Its current new-customer plans are Free, Lite, Pro and Enterprise. Paid-plan costs vary by subscriber tier; use the current quote for the plan and list size you need. Its platform fee on paid subscriptions is 0%, with payment processing still applicable.
Publishing on Substack is free regardless of subscriber count. When you charge for subscriptions, Substack keeps 10% of subscription revenue. Stripe processing is separate. Substack’s US-card example is 2.9% + $0.30 per payment, with a 0.7% Stripe Billing fee on recurring payments. An optional custom domain has a one-time $50 fee.
THE MATH
Model the percentage before assuming it is small.
At $1,000/month in paid-subscription revenue, Substack’s 10% platform share is $100. At $5,000, it is $500. Both figures exclude processing and other charges.
For a hypothetical US-card web subscription payment of $10, the supplied fee model gives $1 to Substack, $0.59 for card processing and $0.07 for recurring billing: $1.66 total, leaving $8.34 before other applicable costs. This example does not cover every country, payment method or in-app purchase.
For a platform-fee-only comparison, let B be beehiiv’s actual monthly-equivalent subscription quote. The point where Substack’s 10% share equals B is paid monthly revenue of 10 × B. This is not an all-in break-even: processing, subscriber-tier changes, migration and required features must also be compared. A 0% platform fee does not mean a free paid-newsletter business.
BEST FIT
Choose the publishing model you want to operate.
beehiiv may fit better when
- Built-in growth and monetization tools are useful.
- Paid revenue makes a 10% platform share expensive.
- Advanced analytics or automation matter.
- You operate the publication as a business.
Substack may fit better when
- You want a simple publishing start.
- You prefer no fixed software subscription.
- Network and discovery simplicity matter.
- Paid revenue is low enough for percentage fees to remain acceptable.
WATCH OUT
Subscriber growth does not guarantee paid growth.
A large free audience and a small paid audience create a different budget from a smaller, highly paid publication. Compare both dimensions. Neither platform guarantees discovery, subscribers or revenue; growth tools only matter if you use them effectively.
Confirm current plan features and payment terms before choosing. These calculations illustrate published terms; they are not hands-on testing or evidence of customer earnings.
SOFTPINION TAKE
Revisit the economics as revenue changes.
Substack can be attractive when a simple start and no fixed software bill matter most. beehiiv can become compelling when integrated publication tools are useful and avoiding a revenue share outweighs its actual subscription cost. Make that decision from your list, paid revenue and workflow, not a universal ranking.
Related analysis: beehiiv pricing · beehiiv vs Kit · Is beehiiv worth it?.
Check the plan against your requirements.
Only beehiiv links are monetized in this comparison. Substack does not compensate Softpinion for this article.
Softpinion may earn a commission if you sign up through links on this page, at no additional cost to you.
See beehiiv plansModel your paid revenue with the beehiiv vs Substack break-even calculator.
SOURCES
Check the underlying facts.
Published vendor terms supply the facts. Workload illustrations and fit conclusions are Softpinion analysis.